Abandonment integrity assessment regarding legacy oil and gas wells and the effects of associated stray gas leakage on the adjacent shallow aquifer in the karoo basin, South Africa

Abstract

Shale gas extraction is underway in the Karoo Basin. Previous oil and gas explorers abandoned several wells, and the abandonment statuses of these wells are unknown. Critically, improperly abandoned wells can provide a pathway for the leakage of stray gas into shallow aquifers and degrade water quality. To understand the abandonment integrity risk posed by these wells, a qualitative risk model was developed to assess the likelihood of well-barrier failure leading to a potential leak. The potential leak paths identified include zones with cement losses during grouting, casing corrosion, cement channels, failure to case and cement risk zones, uncased and uncemented sources, uncemented annuli, and unplugged wells. To confirm whether these wells are leaking, geochemical tracing of stray gas was integrated. Eleven of the fifty samples collected had dissolved hydrocarbon gas concentrations that were high enough to use isotopic analysis to determine the source. The results revealed microbial gas via fermentation and carbon dioxide reduction, thermogenic gas, and geothermal gas, as evidenced by larger δ13C1 values and isotopic reversals associated with dolerite intrusions. The thermogenic-type gas detected in legacy abandoned wells and <1 km water boreholes adjacent to these wells serves as evidence that the downhole plugs did not maintain their integrity or were improperly plugged, whereas the thermogenic gas detected in >1 km water boreholes indicates leakage contamination due to natural fracture pathways. The presence of thermogenic gas in legacy wells and in groundwater boreholes <1 km from legacy wells implies that shale gas extraction using hydraulic fracturing cannot be supported in these situations. However, using safety buffer zones greater than 1 km from the legacy wells for shale gas drilling could be supported.