Faculty of Law

Permanent URI for this community

https://hdl.handle.net/10566/25

The Faculty of Law's principal research focus areas include human rights, local government law, criminal justice and prisons, and labour law.

Electronic theses and dissertations are available in the Electronic Theses and Dissertations Repository.

News

South African institutions top THE Africa rankings pilot

Times Higher Education creates a top 15 table for Africa’s academies ahead of the inaugural THE Africa Universities Summit on 30-31 July

Browse

Now showing 1 - 20 of 1837

The 1996 Constitution and the Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011 : balancing efficient and effective tax administration with taxpayers' rights
(University of the Western Cape, 2016) Moosa, Fareed; De Ville, Jacques R; Croome, Beric J
Taxation is fundamental for development in South Africa (SA), a developing country with an emerging economy in which taxation is essential to capacitate the government so that it can fulfil its mandate under the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (Constitution). This mandate includes bringing about socio-economic transformation, part of transformative constitutionalism, through progressively realising socio-economic rights. This dissertation examines the way in which tax administration may take place efficiently and effectively with due respect for taxpayers' rights. A clear link is shown between taxation, human rights and the South African government's responsibilities to attain its transformation targets. To facilitate this process, the Constitution creates a legal framework for the imposition of tax and for the equitable distribution of tax revenue among the three spheres of government. For historical, political and other reasons, South Africans generally, as happens elsewhere in the world, lack a strong culture of voluntary tax compliance. Wilful non-payment of tax is antithetical to the values of democracy, ubuntu and the rule of law. Tax non-compliance minimises revenue collected from taxation. This, in turn, hinders the attainment of transformation in all its facets. A pressing need exists for laws that, on the one hand, promote tax morality and, on the other, strengthen the South African Revenue Service (SARS) so that it can effectively administer SA's national tax system (or grid). To this end, the Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011 (TAA) is pivotal. It regulates tax administration, a part of public administration. Under the Constitution, SARS is obliged to execute its functions in a manner respectful of taxpayers' rights and that upholds the Constitution’s values and democratic principles. Consequently, the TAA must strike a fair balance between, on the one hand, protecting taxpayers' rights and, on the other, arming SARS with adequate powers with which it can effectively combat the mischief of tax non-compliance. This dissertation shows that, when viewed through the prism of s 36 of the Bill of Rights (BOR), the powers conferred on SARS by ss 45(1), (2), 63(1) and (4) of the TAA to conduct warrantless inspections and searches, as the case may be, limit taxpayers' rights to, inter alia, privacy. It concludes that, whilst ss 63(1) and (4) ought to pass muster, ss 45(1) and (2) are susceptible to a declaration of invalidity under s 172(1) of the Constitution.
2 + 2 = 5? Exploring the domestication of the CRC in South African jurisprudence (2002-2006)
(Brill Academic Publishers, 2008) Sloth-Nielsen, Julia; Mezmur, Benyam Dawit
South Africa commenced transition to a constitutional democracy with the adoption of an interim constitution in 1994, followed by national elections based, for the ﬁ rst time, on universal adult suffrage. A justiciable Bill of Rights, containing some rights accorded to children, was at the core of our new society based on values of dignity, equality and respect for the freedom and security of the person, in sharp contrast to the violence and legalised discrimination that had characterised the apartheid regime. T e two years that followed the adoption of the Interim Constitution were a period of intense negotiations by a multi-party constitutional assembly to ﬁ nalise the text of a ﬁ nal constitution, in accordance with the principles set out in the Interim Constitution. As has previously been pointed out (Sloth-Nielsen, 1996, p.326), there was a high degree of consensus amongst political parties about the children’s rights to be included, to the extent that four of the six party submissions supported the extension of the children’s rights clause, and indeed a number of additional rights were fashioned and ultimately adopted.
The 2010 Kenyan constitution and the hierarchical place of international law in the Kenyan domestic legal system: a comparative perspective
(Pretoria University Law Press (PULP), 2013) Orago, Nicholas Wasonga
The prominent use of international human rights law in a state’s domestic legal system depends on the hierarchical place occupied by international law in general, and international human rights law in particular, among the sources of law in that particular legal system. Two systems of receipt of international law in the domestic legal systems have been used by different states: monism, which looks to directly incorporate ratified international law treaties in a state’s domestic legal system; and dualism, which entails the transformation of international law into the domestic legal system through the domestication of ratified international law treaties by means of the enactment of parliamentary legislation. Kenya, as a Commonwealth country, has always primarily followed a dualist approach which requires that domesticating legislation be enacted by parliament for ratified international law treaties to have application in the domestic legal system. However, with the promulgation of the new Constitution in August 2010, international law has been given a more prominent role in the domestic legal system through the inclusion in the Constitution of a provision directly incorporating ratified treaty law into the Kenyan legal system as a legitimate source of law. This article is primarily focused on analysing the hierarchical place of international law, specifically international human rights treaty law, in the Kenyan domestic legal system in the context of the new constitutional dispensation. It recommends that in order for international human rights law to have a prominent place in the governance of the country, article 2(6) of the Constitution should be interpreted progressively so as to give international human rights law norms an infra-constitutional but a supra-legal status in the domestic legal system. In this way, international human rights law will act as a bulwark against recession to totalitarian rule, as well as safeguard the democratic and fundamental rights protection gains that were won in the struggle for constitutional change.
A child's right to identity in the context of embryo donation: Lessons from Australia and New Zealand, part 2
(North-West Unversity, 2024) Bouah, Nicole; Jacobs, Carmel
In part 1 of this article the current level of protection of the right to identity both at the national and international levels were considered in the case of embryo donation. It was concluded that at a national level the national health act, its accompanying regulations and the children's act fail to protect this right. The constitutional provisions on children's rights are also unhelpful in providing the requisite level of protection. At an international level it was further found that neither the CRC nor the ACRWC explicitly uphold the child's right to identity in the case of embryo donation. In an attempt to address this defect, this article compares the legal protection provided for the right to identity of children born through embryo donation in Australia and New Zealand. A number of lessons can be drawn from this comparative analysis. At a national level the article submits that the birth certificate should indicate the child's true origins and in addition to a register which holds the particulars of the child's donor parents, a separate donor sibling register is also suggested. Legislative amendments are also suggested to parliament.
A child's right to identity in the context of embryo donation: part 1
(North-West Unversity, 2024) Bouah, Nicole; Jacobs, Carmel
This article investigates the extent to which the South African Legislature and the international community recognise the right to identity of a child born through embryo donation. A distinction is drawn between embryo donation, gamete donation and surrogacy. Thereafter, the article discusses the multiple aspects which the right to identity comprises, namely: personal, biological, family and siblingship identity. An assessment is made of how these various aspects are impacted by national and cross-border embryo donation arrangements. The Children's Act 38 of 2005, the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996, the National Health Act 61 of 2003 and the Regulations Relating to Artificial Fertilisation of Persons, in addition to the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) and the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child (ACRWC) are critically examined to the extent that may be applicable to children born through embryo donation. The article concludes that neither the South African legislative framework, nor the CRC or the ACRWC explicitly upholds the child's right to identity
A Critical analysis of section 129 of the companies act 71 of 2008
(University of the Western Cape, 2017) Barends, Richard Heinz; Wandrag, Riekie
A company forms an important part of a community in which it conducts business. It, therefore, has a direct impact on the economic and thus the social well-being of that community through its employees, suppliers and distributors. Consequently, the failure of a company has a large effect on society than merely its employees and creditors. In some instances this may lead to companies being liquidated. Granting an order of liquidation, results in the demise of the corporate entity and the attendant loss of jobs. This is further protracted by an unsatisfactory pro rata share in the residue for unsecured creditors, and the abandonment of claims when such are not proved. Having a corporate rescue procedure in place can prevent or even limit the amount of job losses, or provide an alternative measure as opposed to liquidation of companies. Corporate rescue affords a company a second chance, after having once failed, to restructure its financial affairs and once again become a successful concern.
A critical analysis of the laws which affect the size of the remand detention population in South Africa
(University of the Western Cape, 2024) Davids, Gidean Zion; Albertus, Chesne
Background: The term ‘remand detainee’ means a person detained in a remand detention facility awaiting the finalisation of their trial. Such person has not commenced with serving a sentence or is not already serving a prior sentence. Remand detainees have a unique status, in that they are presumed innocent (if they have not been convicted yet) and are protected by certain rights that do not apply to sentenced offenders. These rights will be discussed later in this chapter. A bail application of an accused person should be seriously considered by the courts and in principle such decision should not easily lead to remand detention where bail is not a just option. Put plainly, when the courts cannot grant bail to the accused, detention should not be the automatic means to ensure the accused’s attendance at his/her trial. There are after all various ways in which the attendance of the accused can be secured at his/her trial.5
Abortion and the right to life: A case study of South Africa and Germany
(University of the Western Cape, 2016) Zimmer, Martina; Mezmur, Benyam Dawit; Machaya, Musavengana
The issue of abortion and the protection of the right to life have been discussed by many academics, yet remains an unresolved topic in many countries. The mere fact that abortion is the deliberate termination of a human pregnancy raises the question, whether or not such an act violates the right to life. Abortion has been legalised in South Africa and Germany. This study explores the area of abortion vis a viz the obligation of South Africa and German under the international and regional human rights instruments to protect the right to life. Notably, the right to life is protected under a plethora of international and regional human rights instruments. At international level, the right to life is protected under Article 3 of the Universal declaration of Human Rights and Article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. At regional level of the right to life is protected by Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights and Article 4 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples� Rights. To give a broad understanding of the meaning, nature and content of the right to life, this mini-thesis shall critically analyse the words used under the above Articles which protect the right to life. Then the paper will endeavour on its main objective which is to determine whether or not the legalisation of Abortion in South Africa and Germany violates the right to life?
Abusing the accused? Unpacking the use of entrapment in Uganda’s fight against corruption
(University of the Western Cape, 2018) Nanima, Robert Doya
In Uganda, an accused person enjoys a right to a fair trial. It is a requirement that the circumstances surrounding the collection and admission of evidence do not violate this right. This article argues that the use of entrapment in cases of corruption may lead to an abuse of the fair trial rights of an accused. The lack of a legislative framework regulating entrapment, the institutional entrenchment of entrapment in the criminal justice system and the inadequate guidance from judgments substantiate this argument. This article recommends amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code Act with a view to preventing abuse of the accused by agents of the criminal justice system.
Access to essential medicines in East Africa: A review of East Africa community and its member states approach to WTO-TRIPS public health flexibilities
(University of the Western Cape, 2018) Majok, Daniel Bol; Lenaghan, Patricia
Magister Legum - LLM (Mercantile and Labour Law)
Access to HIV treatment for refugees : case study of South Africa and Uganda
(University of the Western Cape, 2015) Njiba, Jessica Tshiosha; Durojaye, E
Access to Justice in Kenya in the Context of Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) 16.3 on the Rule of Law: Lessons for the upcoming 2020 Voluntary National Review Report
(CEDRED Publications, 2020-08) Nanima, Robert Doya; Durojaye, Ebenezer
Kenya was among the various countries that presented a Voluntary National Review Report in 2017. In the context of the Sustainable Development Goal 16.3, a close reading of the 2017 Report shows some strong and weak points. Kenya is preparing its second Voluntary National Review Report at the next High-Level Political Forum in 2020. This contribution argues that Kenya can take lessons from its 2017 Report to comprehensively engage issues that speak to Access to Justice under SDG 16.3. First, the contribution contextualizes Sustainable Development Goal 16.3 in Kenya’s context. Secondly, it evaluates and juxtaposes the requirements for the Voluntary National Review Report under the 2020 and the 2017 Guidelines. Thirdly, it evaluates the extent to which the 2017 Voluntary National Review Report ascribed to its guidelines and where the emphasis for the 2020 Report should be. The fifth step is a hint on the way forward; followed by a conclusion. The authors adopt a desktop approach that evaluates available literature, legislation, case law and similar sources. The findings show that until May 2020, the SDG 16.3 did not deal with access to civil justice. Literature has identified the need to engage both formal and informal courts to deal with various societal issues like entrenched inequalities, discrimination and the independence of the judiciary. This study finds that a point of departure from Kenya’s 2017 VNR Report requires that data should be desegregated according to the requirements of SDG 16.3, with a more nuanced approach that links the challenges to access to justice.
Access to reproductive health and rights for indigenous women in Zimbabwe: A case of the San community in Tsholotsho and Plumtree
(University of the Western Cape, 2023) Nkomo, Sindiso Nozitha; Durojaye, Ebenezer
Access to healthcare, including reproductive health, is an essential human right that necessitates the attainment of human development, non-discrimination between genders, and promotes women’s rights. Reproductive health and rights enable women to make independent decisions and choices relating to their bodies and make it possible to keep women healthy, safe, and dignified. Despite this importance, indigenous women often struggle to have access to satisfactory reproductive health services and have poorer outcomes compared to the general populace. Indigenous women from Zimbabwe are not exempt from this predicament. It is against this background that this study aims to interrogate the extent to which San indigenous women in Zimbabwe enjoy access to reproductive health and rights. The elements of reproductive health and rights which are the main focus of this study are: “prevention and treatment of sexually transmitted infections (STIs), including HIV and AIDS and cervical cancer; maternal health; and voluntary informed and affordable family planning services.” Studies have been conducted on access to other rights by San people, such as their right to education and to decide their cultural and ethnical integrity.
Access to safe food in South Africa as a human rights imperative
(University of the Western Cape, 2015) Adeniyi, Oluwafunmilola Foluke; Durojaye, Ebenezer
The aim of this study is to examine laws and policies relating to food safety in South Africa, specifically with regard to labelling requirements in the food industry. It is hoped that this research will serve as a pointer for policy and legislative reforms in a bid to identify weak areas as well as encourage accountability and strengthen government’s response to the realisation of the right to safe food as a human right imperative.
Accession of least developed countries into the world trade organisation: the perspective of south Sudan
(University of Western Cape, 2013) Oliver, Bakadi Sannah; Lenaghan, Patricia
Accession of least developed countries into the world trade organisation: the perspective of south Sudan
(University of Western Cape, 2013) Oliver, Bakadi Sannah; Lenaghan, Patricia
Accountability and the right to food: A comparative study of India and South Africa
(Food Security SA Working Paper Series, 2018) Durojaye, Ebenezer; Chilemba, Enoch MacDonnell
It remains a great source of concern that, as richly endowed as the world is, each day millions of people go to sleep hungry and almost 870 million people, particularly in developing countries, are chronically undernourished. Also, every year, 6 million children die, directly or indirectly, from the consequences of undernourishment and malnutrition – that is, 1 child every 5 seconds. The international community at various forums in the last twenty years or so have committed to ending undernourishment in the world. The right to adequate food is guaranteed in a number of international and regional human rights instruments. Despite these developments, many countries have not lived up to their obligations to realise this right. South Africa and India provide an interesting comparison. On one hand, South Africa has a progressive constitution that explicitly guarantees the right to food, while the Indian Constitution does not recognise the right to food as justiciable right. Yet the Indian courts have developed rich jurisprudence to hold the government accountable for failing to realise the right to food of the people. Indeed the courts have played key roles in ensuring the judicialisation of the right to adequate food in India in the wake of the fact that the Constitution does not expressly set out the right. This report shows that South Africa can learn from the Indian experience by using litigation as a tool for holding the government accountable to its obligation under international and national laws. Besides litigating the right to food to hold the government accountable, it is noted that chapter 9 institutions such as the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC), the Gender Equality Commission and the Public Protector all have important roles to play in holding the government accountable to the realisation of the right to food. This is because these institutions are constitutionally empowered to monitor and report on the measures and steps taken by the government towards the realisation of socioeconomic rights, including the right to food under the Constitution. The report concludes by noting that civil society groups in South Africa will need to be more active in monitoring steps and measures adopted by the government to realise the right to food. It also notes that, where necessary, litigation can be employed as a useful strategy to hold the government to account for its obligation to realise the right to food.
Accountability for ISIS atrocities : is the International Criminal Court a viable prosecutorial option?
(University of the Western Cape, 2016) Dale, Adi Dekebo; Werle, Gerhard
The Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant is a jihadist militant group. The members of this militant group have committed criminal acts of unspeakable cruelty. These staggering criminal conducts are documented by the United Nations, international human rights organisations, and media. Besides, the group itself gives first-hand information through social media and its magazine. Having witnessed the atrocities committed by Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, the United Nations Security Council affirmed that the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant’s conduct in Syria and Iraq is a threat to international peace and security. Therefore, the media and various role players have called for the intervention of International Criminal Court. This research paper analyses whether the International Criminal Court is a viable prosecutorial option to account the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant members for their crimes. For the Court to be a viable prosecutorial avenue, it must have a jurisdiction. Accordingly, this research paper critically examines whether the International Criminal Court has subject matter, personal and/or territorial jurisdictions to try the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant perpetrators. The study concludes that although the criminal conducts by Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant members constitute crimes under the Rome Statute, the Court, however, has limited jurisdictional reach over the perpetrators. It is submitted that with a limited and fragmented territorial and personal jurisdictional reach over the perpetrators, the Court is not a viable prosecutorial avenue.
The accountability of juveniles for crimes under international law
(University of the Western Cape, 2016) Nortje, Windell; Werle, Gerhard
Children have been committing crimes during times of war and other armed conflicts since time immemorial. Yet, it is only over the last few decades that cognisance is being taken of child soldiers as a type of juvenile. The unfortunate sight of a child holding a gun has become a familiar picture throughout armed conflicts, especially in Africa. Both boys and girls are used as child soldiers and they can be as young as 5 years old. They are mainly regarded as victims of crimes under international law and are therefore usually rehabilitated once they have been disarmed and demobilised. Notwithstanding their need for rehabilitation, it is a fact that child soldiers commit some of the most egregious crimes under international law. They receive military-style training and are presumably not afraid of killing and carrying out orders. Yet it is recognised that generally they do not have the same level of maturity as adults. The reality of child soldiers who join armed forces therefore presents complex legal questions in the face of contemporary international criminal law principles which, on the one hand, afford protection to all children, and on the other, unequivocally call for the prosecution and punishment of those who are individually responsible for committing crimes under international law. Consequently, various safeguards need to be upheld to ensure that the best interests of the child are maintained once a child soldier is held criminally responsible. This thesis analyses the extent to which child soldiers can be prosecuted under domestic and international law, as well as the implementation of alternative measures to prosecution. The thesis proposes that a case-by-case approach should be considered when child soldiers are prosecuted for crimes under international law, thereby investigating and analysing the often distinctive circumstances related to their crimes.
The active and passive voting rights of convicted prisoners in South Africa and the United Kingdom
(University of the Western Cape, 2014) Bekeer, Cindy-Lee Neavera; Le Roux, Wessel
The purpose of this mini-thesis is to assess the present position regarding prisoner disenfranchisement in South Africa from a human rights perspective, and to recommend reforms of South African electoral legislation as far as prisoners‘ voting rights are concerned.

Browse

Browsing by Title

Results Per Page

Sort Options